November 23, 2026

Vape rules landed on compliant retailers, not on 490,000 daily vapers

Bright neon sign of a vape shop in a city window reflecting the urban street.

Two years of progressively tougher vaping rules have produced a striking result. Roughly 490,000 New Zealanders still vape daily, the national rate has barely shifted, and the cost of the crackdown fell mostly on the retailers who actually complied.

That is the worst kind of regulation for business. It is heavy enough to impose real costs on legitimate operators, and too lightly enforced to hit its target.

A flat line after the toughest tranche yet

The Ministry of Health’s 2025/26 Health Survey puts daily vaping among adults at 11.2%, similar to the previous two years and well above the 6.4% recorded five years ago. This is the first full dataset since the June 2025 measures took effect.

Those measures capped a long run of tightening. Between September 2023 and June 2025, the government restricted where specialist stores could locate, cut product visibility in general retail, banned youth-appealing packaging and flavour names, capped nicotine levels and outlawed disposables.

The young adults the rules were built to protect have not budged. Analysis from the Public Health Communication Centre shows 137,000 daily vapers are aged 15-24, and daily vaping among 18-24-year-olds sits at 25.7%, with no significant reduction from the regulatory changes. The genuine bright spot is the youngest cohort, where daily vaping among 15-17-year-olds fell from 12.8% to 8.0%. That is a real gain and deserves credit. It is also the only one.

The spending data tells the same story. In March 2026, RNZ’s analysis of Dot Loves Data bank transactions found New Zealanders spent $401 million on vaping products in 2025, down from $417 million in 2024, a drop of about 4%. Spending among over-35s held steady or rose even as prices climbed. Vaping Industry Association chair Jonathan Devery told RNZ at the time that the disposable ban had the single biggest effect on sales. The blunt instrument worked. The finer-grained display and packaging rules did far less.

Contrast that with smoking, where daily rates fell to 5.9% from 6.7% a year earlier. Long-run, consistently enforced policy delivers. Vaping policy, so far, has not.

Half the shops were not playing by the rules

The most damning evidence is a University of Otago compliance audit published in May 2026. Researchers checked 87 specialist vape retailers in metropolitan Wellington after the June 2025 restrictions took effect and found 52% were non-compliant with at least one measure. Products were visible from outside 24% of stores, 40% displayed disallowed advertising, and 48% did not ask for age verification from customers who appeared under 25.

Only 5% still sold disposables, so the ban itself largely held. But 89% of stores offered reusable starter kits for $15 or less, undercutting the price deterrent the ban was supposed to create. The researchers concluded that “non-compliance with youth protection measures was widespread” and that cheap reusables may undermine the law’s goals.

None of this was a surprise. In June 2025, before the reforms took effect, public health researchers Jude Ball, Janet Hoek and Richard Edwards warned that “poor compliance is widespread, and poses a major threat to the effectiveness of these new measures.” They were right almost to the letter.

Compliance becomes a tax on the honest

For a legitimate retailer, the rules meant relocation constraints, display redesigns, packaging changes, reformulated stock and the loss of an entire product category. Those costs are fixed and real. Meanwhile, a competitor that skips ID checks and keeps its window display still captures the demand. Under-enforced regulation does not level the playing field. It tilts it towards whoever is willing to ignore it.

Adults are caught in the middle

The industry argues the rules also hit the wrong users. A 2025 VIANZ survey of 762 adult vapers found 6% had already returned to smoking, more than 10% were considering it, and 29% said their preferred products were no longer available. Devery said at the time that “the pendulum has swung too far.” Treat an industry survey with appropriate caution, but the direction is plausible.

Public health academics reach a different diagnosis with a similar conclusion. A 2025 peer-reviewed analysis found New Zealand moved slowly compared with the UK and Australia, and that its policies “lacked strength” when they did arrive. Too weak for public health, too disruptive for adult harm reduction. Both camps are describing the same muddled middle.

Enforce before you legislate again

The reflexive response to flat numbers will be another layer of rules, whether tighter flavour bans, licensing or further retail restrictions. The evidence points the other way. The existing rules are barely being enforced, and adding more on paper will simply raise costs for compliant operators again.

Fund inspections, prosecute repeat offenders and make non-compliance genuinely expensive. Until that happens, the 490,000-customer market will keep flowing to whoever ignores the rulebook. That lesson applies well beyond vaping, to any sector facing a fresh wave of consumer protection rules: regulation without enforcement is just a cost imposed on the people who were already doing the right thing.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required