November 22, 2026

Your law firm’s file management is a supplier risk nobody audits

Close-up of a businesswoman organizing files in a black box in an office setting.

If a building contractor stopped answering calls for months, kept your documents for half a year and left you guessing whether they would turn up on the day that mattered, you would terminate the contract and probably sue. When a lawyer does the same thing, most businesses wait it out. A run of Law Society standards committee decisions suggests that patience is misplaced.

The failures in these cases are not exotic ethical lapses. They are basic process breakdowns, the kind any competent procurement team would screen for in any other supplier. Legal advice simply gets treated as a black box.

Radio silence before the Court of Appeal

The latest example, reported by the NZ Herald today, involves two lawyers found to have engaged in unsatisfactory conduct after personal crises led them to stop communicating with clients. One, a family lawyer winding up her practice while dealing with mental health difficulties, left her client uncertain until the day before a Court of Appeal hearing whether she would appear. After the hearing, nothing. The file was not returned for roughly six months, and only after a complaint was lodged.

The committee described the post-hearing conduct as “radio silence” that left the client unsupported and vulnerable. The practical cost was concrete: she lost the chance to take further action on the judgment. The second lawyer failed to respond to a client for months before terminating the retainer following a family member’s death.

Hardship is not a continuity plan

Both decisions accepted the personal circumstances were real. Neither accepted them as an excuse. A separate decision this year put the principle plainly, ruling that systems should be in place to keep responding to clients even when an individual practitioner is struggling.

That is the right standard, and it is the same one businesses apply everywhere else. Key-person risk is a familiar concept in any supply chain. A firm that cannot cover for a lawyer who falls ill has a resilience problem, not a compassion problem.

The failures look like operations, not ethics

Read the decisions as a set and the pattern is about systems. In a relationship property case this year, a junior lawyer failed to disclose a valuation schedule, missed that his client would keep her former partner’s debt, overlooked a penalty clause and signed the settlement memorandum himself. His supervisor was reprimanded and ordered to pay $12,000 compensation and refund fees for inadequately supervising him on a complex file.

In a case reported in January 2025, a lawyer misplaced a trust client’s documents for eight months, assuming she had taken them, before finding them in the firm’s own files. By then she had lost legal capacity and her instructions could never be carried out. The firm had still billed her. The lawyer was ordered to refund the invoice and pay a $3,000 fine plus $2,500 costs.

And in a 2023 Otago decision, two partners were found to have acted on a matter despite a conflict of interest the firm had already identified. The committee pointed to a breakdown in communication between partners and a possible failure of the systems the firm’s own terms of engagement said were in place. Policies on paper, in other words, with no operational discipline behind them.

The regulator is too slow to be your safety net

In December 2025, RNZ reported that 1,366 complaints were referred to standards committees in the year to June 2025, up 11 percent, with 566 alleging negligence or incompetence. Katie Rusbatch, the Law Society’s chief executive at the time, attributed much of the rise to a larger profession and greater awareness of complaint rights, and noted that the incompetence category covers everything from minor matters to delays.

That explanation is fair, and it would be wrong to read the figures as a profession in collapse. But the more relevant number for business is the timeline. Complaints took an average of nine months to resolve, and more than 80 percent ended with no further action. A business facing a settlement deadline or a compliance window cannot outsource its risk management to that process.

What to demand before you sign the retainer

The fixes are unglamorous. Insist on a clear letter of engagement at the outset that sets out who is doing the work and who is supervising. Ask directly how the firm oversees junior lawyers on complex matters, because that was the failure behind the largest compensation order. Write file-continuity and handover expectations into long-running retainers. Agree response times, and treat vague or slow communication as an early warning rather than something to tolerate.

None of this is hostile to lawyers. Most firms already run these systems and will welcome clients who ask about them. The point is that legal services deserve the same supplier scrutiny as any other critical input. The committees are now saying firms need systems that survive a bad month. Clients should start checking whether they actually do.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required