November 22, 2026

Friction at the cancel button is now evidence against you

Person using laptop with payment failure message on screen and plant beside it.

Every recurring-revenue business knows the trick. Make joining effortless, make leaving tedious, and let customer inertia do the rest. Designers call it a “roach motel”, and Stuff’s latest consumer warning shows the term has escaped the UX textbooks and reached the mainstream. That matters, because once a retention tactic has a pejorative name, it stops being clever and starts being evidence.

The businesses still relying on cancellation friction are not outsmarting their customers. They are building a regulatory case against themselves.

The watchdog is already counting

The complaint trend is not subtle. Commerce Commission data released in 2025 showed subscription trap complaints rising from 49 in 2020/21 to a peak of 412 in 2023/24, an eightfold jump, with 786 over five years. A later 2025 response found 167 of 304 subscription concerns in the preceding 12 months involved cancellation difficulties specifically, from confusing steps to hidden options and forcing customers to phone in. The Commission said plainly that this conduct can breach the Fair Trading Act.

Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Cameron Brewer has reinforced the point. He says “in general it should be easy and straightforward to cancel subscriptions“, and confirms subscription traps are a current Commission enforcement priority. When a centre-right minister who is generally wary of piling on regulation is saying this, businesses should take it as a signal, not a suggestion.

HelloFresh showed what retention costs when it crosses the line

If anyone thought this was theoretical, HelloFresh NZ settled that in 2025. The meal-kit company was fined $845,000 after cold-calling former customers under the guise of feedback surveys and offering vouchers without clearly disclosing that accepting them would restart paid subscriptions.

The sentencing decision is the part every board should read. Between February 2022 and July 2023, HelloFresh reactivated 89,156 cancelled subscriptions, charging between $55 and $163 without express consent and sending 1,105 customers to debt collectors. And 43,615 of those reactivated customers cancelled again before two boxes arrived, despite 40% discounts. So the tactic produced a fine, debt-collection write-offs and a public judgment, while retaining very few customers who actually wanted to stay. That is not retention. It is churn with extra steps and legal costs.

Customers are finding their own exits

The consumer cost is large enough to keep this on the political agenda. In February 2026, RNZ reported Consumer NZ estimates that New Zealanders lost more than $60 million a year to dark patterns, with almost 30% saying they kept paying because unsubscribing was too hard. A Consumer NZ survey reported in 2025 found 40% had hit cancellation problems caused by dark patterns.

Frustrated customers do not quietly give up forever. One subscriber in that 2026 RNZ report described cancelling as “nightmarish” and ended up removing her card details entirely to stop renewals. Back in 2024, Labour MP Cushla Tangaere-Manuel said she had cancelled a credit card to escape one. When customers route around you through their bank, you lose the relationship, the data and any chance of a win-back offer.

The law is narrowing the room to manoeuvre

The Fair Trading Amendment Bill is before select committee, and Consumer NZ argues it does not go far enough, pushing for an Australia-style ban on unfair trading practices. Labour’s proposed Fair Go Act would require cancellation to be as easy as sign-up.

University of Auckland commercial law professor Alex Sims is sceptical new law alone will fix it, because “a significant number of businesses ignore consumer protection laws“. Her review of NZ terms found every contract she examined contained at least one clause breaching unfair contract terms provisions. Her verdict on roach motels is blunt: “Businesses should not be able to build their business models around customer frustration and consequent inaction.”

None of this is a New Zealand quirk. Peer-reviewed research in 2024 documented manipulative cancellation flows across four countries, and that year Wynn Williams partner Paul Comrie-Thomson warned NZ firms that online choice architecture was an increasing area of regulatory focus after US action against Adobe.

Fix it before someone fixes it for you

The pro-business case here is simple. Good businesses should not need a regulator to tell them to stop trapping customers, and the less of this conduct there is, the weaker the argument for heavy-handed rules like a blanket unfair-practices ban. Every firm that hides its cancel button hands ammunition to those who want broader regulation for everyone.

For SaaS providers, gyms, telcos, media and subscription retailers, the arithmetic has flipped. A clean, one-step cancellation costs some churn. Friction now risks fines, write-offs, bank disputes and a judgment with your name on it. Audit the flow this quarter, make leaving as easy as joining, and compete on the reasons people stay. The select committee will finish its work either way. Better to be ahead of it than the case study cited in it.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required