The Financial Markets Authority spends its working life telling banks, insurers and fund managers how to run healthy cultures. Its own has been haemorrhaging. BusinessDesk revealed this week that more than 280 people have left the FMA since 2021, from an organisation employing just over 300. That is close to a full turnover of the workforce in five years.
Treat that as a staffing story and you miss the point. Supervision runs on people who know the files, the firms and the history behind both. Every resignation takes some of that institutional memory out the door, and the regulated community is left dealing with new faces, slower guidance and inconsistent calls.
The exit survey hides more than it shows
About 160 leavers completed an exit survey, and “career opportunity” topped the stated reasons. The survey excludes fixed-term and casual staff and anyone who left involuntarily, including redundancies, a gap interim chief executive Alastair Hercus defends on the basis that surveying those people would be disrespectful. An unnamed industry expert was blunter, saying career opportunity “can mask a whole series of evils” because in a market this small nobody wants to burn a reference.
The warning lights were flashing for a year
None of this arrived without notice. In 2025, NBR reported more than 50 resignations that calendar year plus 25 redundancies, while the FMA described underlying turnover as steady. In May 2026, NBR reported an MBIE review had surfaced a police complaint and allegations of stalking, harassment and intimidation inside the regulator.
An internal survey run in late 2025 found only 59% of staff saw a future for themselves at the FMA, even though 80% believed their work mattered. That is the profile of committed people being pushed out, not drifting off. In September, then-chief executive Samantha Barrass resigned with months left on her contract, as a workplace inquiry led by Kristy McDonald KC got underway and details emerged of a restructure that cut 14 roles, created 41 and cost roughly $1.7 million, including more than $800,000 in redundancies.
The churn is not a one-off spike either. Rolling voluntary turnover reached 13% at June 2025, up from 11.9% a year earlier. Back in 2022, the FMA was already citing a growing remit, including the conduct regime for banks and insurers and climate-related disclosures, as a pressure on staffing. The workload has only grown since. The bench has not kept pace.
A surplus nobody should celebrate
The FMA’s 2025/26 annual report shows a surplus of $2.61 million against a budgeted $1.75 million deficit, driven largely by underspending on salaries, its biggest cost line. Fiscal conservatives normally cheer an agency that comes in under budget. This is not that. The regulator saved money because it could not keep seats filled, while levy-paying firms and taxpayers funded supervision that did not happen.
The regulated community has noticed. Agreement that the FMA’s approach is proportionate and beneficial fell from 55% to 42% in a year, and ratings of its effectiveness implementing remit changes slipped from 54% in 2024 to 50%.
Deterrence is the real casualty
The most damaging line in this saga came from a prominent fund manager: “I’m not that scared of the FMA”. A pro-business reader should not take comfort in that. Light-touch regulation is a policy choice; a weak regulator is an accident. Firms want rules applied predictably and bad actors punished, because the honest operators bear the reputational cost when cowboys go unchecked. A conduct regulator that cannot hold its own culture together struggles to lecture anyone else on theirs.
The board gap Parliament never closed
Roger Partridge of The New Zealand Initiative argues this is a design flaw, not just one bad workplace. Parliament separated the FMA’s board from management in 2011, but robust appointments and independent performance checks were, in his words, “never built”. Only 21.8% of businesses surveyed by the Initiative believed anyone holds regulators to account when they perform badly.
That is the question for Commerce Minister Cameron Brewer. The McDonald inquiry will produce findings about behaviour and individuals. The harder task is building the accountability machinery that would have caught this years earlier. If the next annual report shows turnover still climbing and another salary underspend, the market will draw its own conclusion, and the fund managers who stopped being scared will not start again on their own.
Sources
- BusinessDesk: More than 300 staff have left FMA since 2021, amid workplace culture issues (2026-11-22)
- BusinessDesk: Inside the crisis at the Financial Markets Authority (2026-09-06)
- NZ Herald: FMA workplace culture issues, MBIE engages with board on ‘next steps’ after multiple complaints (2026-07-31)
- Law News: Who watches the watchdog? Amid claims of bullying, the financial markets’ regulator now faces an inquiry into its own culture and conduct (2026-08-06)
- FMA: Annual Report 2025/26 (2026)
- FMA: OIA request for information – FMA turnover, demographics and use of contractors (2022-11-28)
- NZ Initiative: The two-thirds we never built (2026-08-21)
Join the discussion
Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.