New Plymouth has voted to rip out the concrete separators on its ‘Tim Tam Alley’ cycleway. The lesson for every council in the country is not that cycleways fail. This one was designed for a drawing board, not for a working street with dairies, driveways and delivery vans, and the people running businesses on Devon Street West said so from day one.
A free build with an expensive exit
Councillors voted at an extraordinary meeting on 18 November to remove the separators between Morley St and Belair Ave, acting on Mayor Max Brough’s recommendation. The cycleway cost $3.8 million, fully funded by NZTA’s Transport Choices programme, so ratepayers paid nothing for the build.
They may pay for the removal. The council estimates up to $300,000, none of it budgeted, and NZTA contributes nothing. If the road surface is damaged, NZTA could demand a reseal estimated at $1.6 million. Brough has drawn a hard line: “There’s a contingency in that $300,000 for damage repairs, but if it fails drastically the work will be ceased. I am not spending a penny more.”
That is a sensible fiscal stance, and it also means the vote is not the end of the story. The council’s own release confirms removal still needs NZTA approval, detailed design, a safety assessment and procurement before work over the summer holidays, with painted cycle lanes reinstated as NZTA requires.
The warning signs were there before the concrete
In June 2025, then-mayor Neil Holdom acknowledged the project “was always going to be controversial”, with submissions split 50/50. A council that knows half its community opposes a project, and builds it anyway with someone else’s money, is making a political bet rather than a planning decision.
The bet lost quickly. Local businessman Shane Devlin organised a survey that drew more than 7,000 responses and found only 2% support for the separators, presented in September 2025 to Shane Jones, then the regional development minister. Brough made removal a central plank of his campaign and won the October 2025 election.
The council’s own August 2025 design review was damning. It found 10 of 36 compliance criteria non-compliant and eight only partially compliant, noted separators being struck on curves, and flagged bus stop layouts that confused users. Roughly half of on-street parking was lost along the corridor. That audit was reportedly not released until after the election.
What the street actually paid
The commercial damage was not abstract. In 2025, Belt Rd Dairy owner Kaushik Patel said his revenue fell 50-60% after the car parks outside his store disappeared. For a small convenience retailer living on quick stops, parking is the business model.
Tyre shops told the same story from the other side. Lizzie Stachurski of Top Town Wheel & Tyre said in 2025 her business was repairing damaged tyres daily, while Bodie Taylor of Simpsons Tyres & Auto Care reported four damaged tyres and rims in a single morning. When infrastructure generates a repair industry, the design has failed.
The council tried to save it. A $200,000 trial of softer rubber separators ran from May to September 2026 and attracted 1,597 submissions. Even then, 59.7% were dissatisfied against 22.9% satisfied. The problem was never only the concrete. It was the whole corridor.
Cyclists weren’t sold either
This is not a simple cars-versus-bikes fight. Some cyclists wanted the separators kept and extended. Others got hurt by them: cyclist Jeff Allan crashed after his pedal clipped a Tim Tam, leaving him unable to ride for months. When the people a project is meant to protect are split, and some are injured by it, the design brief has gone wrong.
National data backs that reading. A December 2025 survey of more than 1,000 New Zealanders found support for urban cycleway investment outweighed opposition, 41% to 35%. The same analysis listed what makes projects stick, including mitigating impacts on business and time-limited trials with clear success criteria. New Plymouth trialled after building, not before.
Businesses are still waiting for their parking
Here is the sting for Devon Street West traders. The council has pushed parking restoration into the 2027-2037 Long-Term Plan. Councillor David Bublitz wanted removal and parking handled together so road markings were done once, but his amendment was ruled out. New rules requiring 1.5 metres of clearance for cyclists may also complicate simply putting the old car parks back.
So the separators may go this summer, painted lanes will return, and the parks that dairy owners and residents actually need sit in a planning queue. If the reseal risk materialises, Brough’s own line means the Tim Tams could stay anyway.
Every council eyeing a transport project should treat this as a checklist. Free central funding is not free if the community rejects it. A 50/50 split is a stop sign, not a mandate. And if the corner dairy is telling you it will lose half its trade, that is not noise from a vocal minority. It is the most important submission in the pile.
Sources
- ODT: Councillors vote to tear up $3.8m ‘Tim Tam Alley’ cycleway (2026-11-18)
- RNZ: New Plymouth councillors vote to rip up Tim Tam Alley cycleway (2026-11-18)
- NPDC: Council votes to remove Devon West cycle separators this summer (2026-11-19)
- RNZ: New Plymouth council to undertake safety audit of new cycleway (2025-06-06)
- Taranaki Media: Tim Tam Cycleway Survey Presented to Minister Shane Jones, Shows Overwhelming Opposition (2025-09-14)
- RNZ: Controversial New Plymouth cycleway ‘Tim Tam Alley’ could be on the way out under new mayor (2025-10-14)
- NPDC: SH45 Devon Street West Cycle Infrastructure Post-Construction Design Review (2025-08)
- The Post: Tyre companies propped up by cycle separator collisions (2025-06-03)
- NPDC: Councillors to decide future of Devon Street West cycle separators (2026-11-13)
- PHCC: Public support for investing in urban cycleways outweighs opposition (2025-12-16)
Join the discussion
Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.