The 2026 election produced an 11-seat overhang, the largest in MMP’s 30-year history, and 46 electoral experts now want Parliament to close the loophole. Most coverage frames this as a question of democratic fairness. For business, the sharper problem is predictability. If the seat count can be engineered away from the vote count, the link between what voters choose and what policy you end up living with gets weaker, and coalition formation gets messier.
From accident to strategy
Every previous overhang, in 2005, 2008, 2011, 2014 and 2023, was inadvertent. This one was not. Te Pāti Māori won five of seven Māori seats on just 0.57% of the party vote, while National won 42 electorates against a party-vote entitlement of 35, pushing Parliament to 131 seats.
Te Pāti Māori asked for split votes openly at its Gisborne campaign launch. On the right, billionaire Harry Mowbray’s Split Your Vote campaign helped build National’s surplus, and he says he has no intention of stopping. Labour’s Kieran McAnulty put it bluntly: “The genie is out of the bottle now and I suspect it’s going to be a feature of MMP moving forward unless changes are made.”
Neither side gets to claim the high ground here. Both blocs have now demonstrated the tactic works.
The threshold for flipping a government is low
The New Zealand Initiative’s Unravelling MMP report is the number boardrooms should remember. Its modelling found that if one in nine National voters split strategically, the governing coalition would win a majority that polling denied it. If one in four did so, the coalition could take 69 of 132 seats even with opposition parties collectively winning more votes.
That is not a freak result. It is a known exploit with a measurable trigger, and it cuts both ways. Andrew Geddis, one of the letter’s organisers, warned the overhang could deliver three parties holding a majority of seats while receiving fewer votes than the other four. Co-organiser Max Rashbrooke expects the next election to become “an arms race”.
A government whose majority rests on tactical arithmetic rather than a clear popular mandate is more vulnerable to legitimacy fights, more cautious about bold reform and more exposed to reversal next time. Long-dated investment decisions do not like that.
The talent cost nobody priced
There is a quieter cost. National’s overhang strategy meant its supporters deprived their own party of Nicola Willis, Paul Goldsmith and Chris Bishop, who between them carried 18 ministerial portfolios. Finance, justice and infrastructure expertise does not regrow overnight. The same analysis warns normalised strategic voting would reduce the party’s leverage in coalition talks and shrink its cabinet presence.
For firms dealing with government on tax settings, consenting or major projects, ministerial churn is a direct continuity risk, whichever side of politics it hits.
How quickly this escalated
The contrast with recent history is stark. In 2020, Parliament recorded its fifth overhang-free MMP election, with only five parties returned. Pre-election boundary changes were routine, trimming general electorates to 64 while Māori seats stayed at seven. Six years later, nine parties and a bloated House.
The experts’ letter, backed by figures including Sir Geoffrey Palmer, sets out five options: more list seats, fewer electorates, stripping overhang seats, a single-vote system, or weighting votes in the House by party-vote share. The Greens have signalled support, with co-leader Marama Davidson calling for “real changes in the law” rather than another shelved report, while insisting Māori electorates be protected.
Pick the fix that does not grow the payroll
Nick Clark of The New Zealand Initiative made the business case before the letter landed: “Businesses need confidence in how governments are chosen and the policies they pursue.” He reviewed Germany’s 2023 reform, which denies seats to electorate winners lacking party-vote support, alongside growing Parliament to roughly 170 MPs.
A 170-seat House is the worst answer for taxpayers and the easiest for politicians. Germany-style removal of unsupported seats, or rebalancing electorates against list seats, fixes the incentive without expanding the payroll. The goal, as The Conversation argues, is to tune MMP, not scapegoat it.
The window is this term
Clark is right that there is no painless fix. But the 2012 recommendations to abolish overhangs gathered dust, and 2026 is the bill. The parties that benefited this time have the least incentive to act, which is exactly why business groups should push. If Parliament leaves the loophole open, expect both blocs to run the play harder in 2029, and expect the policy outlook to be decided by tactical voting campaigns rather than voters’ actual preferences.
Sources
- Stuff: 46 electoral experts sign open letter calling MMP reform (2026-11-18)
- RNZ: ‘Not the way MMP was supposed to work’: Experts urge politicians to act on overhang (2026-11-18)
- The Post: Greens back push to keep MMP proportional, say Māori seats must be protected (2026-11-17)
- The Spinoff: ‘The genie is out of the bottle’: The fight to fix MMP begins (2026-11-16)
- The New Zealand Initiative: Unravelling MMP (2026)
- The Conversation: Disproportional representation, what National wins and loses from the overhang (2026-11-09)
- The Conversation: The election was an ‘MMP special’, now’s the time to tune the system, not scapegoat it (2026-11-17)
- NZ Herald: Election 2026, how can we stop overhangs stealing an election? (2026-10-14)
- Stats NZ: General electorates down by one, number of Māori electorates stays at seven (2024-10-23)
- NZ Parliament: The 2020 General Election and referendums (2021-04)
Join the discussion
Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.