November 18, 2026

Jarden’s phone-clone win is a device policy warning for every employer

Focused businessman using a smartphone and laptop in an office setting, engaging in multitasking.

The Jarden-Barrenjoey fight started as finance-sector gossip about a talent raid. It has turned into the clearest lesson New Zealand employers have had on what happens when client relationships, senior exits and a mobile phone collide. On 18 November the Employment Court gave Jarden what NBR calls the right to search phone data belonging to former co-CEO Dan Reynolds and co-head of investment banking Silvana Schenone, setting what the paper describes as an important precedent for employer rights when staff defect to competitors.

The catch is that Jarden does not get to look. And that detail matters more to the average business owner than who wins the war.

A raid that took the whole bench

Reynolds and Schenone resigned on 27 July to join Australian rival Barrenjoey, whose New Zealand entity appeared on the Companies Office register days earlier. More staff followed. In August, Jarden told the court the raid left no business division untouched, with its counsel Brian Dickey KC arguing it must have been aided from within and accusing the defectors of destroying evidence.

The evidence in question sits on two phones. A few days after resigning, the pair’s lawyers had data recovery firm Datalab clone the devices, which were then factory reset. Jarden’s camp sees a wiped trail. The executives’ counsel, Philip Skelton KC, sees the opposite, telling the court the clones were taken “so that issues around who owns what on the phone could be determined appropriately”.

The court sided with process, not the employer

Jarden did not get here easily. Its first attempt to force the data’s return failed in August, and the bank had to come back with a tighter application. The final order sends the clones to independent solicitor Kirsti Laird, assisted by forensic firm Incident Response Solutions, who will pull out Jarden’s confidential information while filtering out privileged and personal material.

Jarden’s hand was strengthened by its own paperwork. Judge Kathryn Beck noted the executives used phones purchased or reimbursed by Jarden and that, “with limited exceptions, Jarden’s policy prohibits employees from using non-company technology for work purposes”. Even so, Schenone had brought her own phone under a BYOD arrangement when she joined in 2022, which is exactly the kind of grey zone that turns a confidentiality claim into months of litigation.

Cybersecurity firm KIS puts the principle bluntly: ownership of a device, entitlement to business information and authority to examine personal information are related but separate questions. Your IT administrator being able to retrieve something does not mean you are entitled to read it, a distinction the Privacy Act 2020 makes expensive to ignore.

Fidelity starts before the resignation letter

The deeper legal question is what happened before 27 July. Tompkins Wake partner Daniel Erickson points to the twin duties departing staff carry, confidentiality and fidelity, with fidelity biting hardest while an employee is still on the payroll and quietly planning a move. A rival registering a local company days before a coordinated walkout is the sort of timeline that makes a fidelity case interesting, though no court has made any finding on it.

That is worth stressing. This ruling is about getting evidence into neutral hands, not a verdict on wrongdoing by Barrenjoey or anyone who left.

The at-risk list is longer than the exit list

KIS also flagged that at least 17 other Jarden staff reportedly discussed joining Barrenjoey but stayed, widening the risk population well beyond those who walked. Its question for every board is whether the organisation can recognise it has entered a period of elevated insider risk before anyone resigns. Most cannot.

For business owners, the practical lessons are not complicated:

  • Write the device policy now. Jarden had one, and it carried weight. A loose BYOD culture hands departing staff a ready-made privacy argument.
  • Move fast after a senior exit. The executives’ side engaged forensic specialists within days. Whoever preserves the evidence first shapes the dispute.
  • Expect a gatekeeper. Courts want independent review where personal and business data are mixed. Build that expectation into employment agreements and response plans.
  • Hire clean. KIS recommends firms recruiting from rivals issue new devices, run confidentiality briefings and apply data loss prevention controls from day one.

A template, not a trophy

The substantive fight, likely to wind through the Employment Relations Authority and the court, is far from over. But the procedural template is already set. Employers with clear, enforceable device and data clauses, and the discipline to accept that personal material is off limits, can get at their own confidential information. Those relying on goodwill and a shared iPhone will find the court far less sympathetic. In a market as small and concentrated as New Zealand’s, where a single rival can lift a whole team in a week, that is not a finance-sector problem. It is everyone’s.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required