Buying off the plan is usually pitched as a consumer story: read the contract, hire a good lawyer, mind the fine print. That framing misses the bigger point. Presale contracts are what developers take to the bank. When buyers stop trusting that the deal they sign will still make commercial sense at settlement, the problem is not confined to one apartment. It moves up the chain into project finance.
The clause that can change sides
Property lawyer Sue Foley, owner of Landley Law, says she has frank conversations with buyers whose “risk appetite isn’t sufficient to buy off plan”. Between signing and settlement, interest rates and values can move, hitting debt servicing and LVR compliance, though the same volatility can also work in a buyer’s favour.
She flags three traps: sunset clauses, price escalation clauses that let developers lift the price if construction costs rise, and substitution clauses allowing changes to materials and appliances. On sunset clauses she is blunt about the Covid-era pattern, saying some developers “might deliberately delay the issue of title and code because the market has moved and they know darn well they could cancel the contract and sell it to another buyer for more money.” Her fix is a written warranty that the developer will not cancel purely to resell higher.
Covid showed what the clause was really worth
Sunset clauses were designed to protect buyers from projects that drag on forever. In a rising market, that protection inverted. In March 2021, with Auckland prices up 20% over the year, developers had an obvious incentive to run down the clock. Later that year, Auckland lawyer Joanna Pidgeon told RNZ that developers were using sunset clauses to void contracts and resell, with first-home buyers hit hardest. Dylan Mann, then a director at Advice Hub, put it more bluntly in 2021: “If the developer won’t remove the clause, run a mile.”
The fallout lingered. In 2023, Fair Go documented a buyer whose sunset date was extended four times, from June 2022 through to June 2024, with her 10% deposit tied up the entire time after her original developer went into receivership.
Presales are the finance, not the paperwork
Here is what consumer coverage tends to skip. Developers use presales to secure their construction finance, which gives them structural leverage once contracts are signed. But that leverage cuts both ways. In May 2025, the Reserve Bank found developer borrowing was constrained by low presales and weak demand, with banks easing presale requirements for some developers just to keep lending moving.
That is the tell. When banks relax the very thresholds meant to de-risk a project, the presale model is under strain. Officials have also noted that undercapitalised developers can struggle to enforce presale commitments, while better-capitalised operators gain ground as weaker rivals pause or fold. For well-funded developers, that is a genuine opportunity.
Parliament left it to the contract
Labour MP Ingrid Leary’s members’ bill would have barred vendors from cancelling off-the-plan contracts without every purchaser’s written consent or a court order. In August 2025 the coalition voted it down along party lines, arguing it risked deterring developers from offering off-the-plan sales at all.
That call was defensible. A court-order regime layered on a fragile presale market could easily have choked off supply. Pidgeon herself noted at the time that softening prices meant developers were desperate to hold presales, not cancel them. Back in March 2024 she had already observed that “if developers can get pre-sales, they’ll be trying to hang on to them”.
But rejecting regulation puts the onus squarely on the industry. If contracts are to carry the weight instead of statute, developers need to offer the kind of anti-flip warranties Foley recommends without being dragged to them.
Consents are up, building isn’t
The timing matters. Building consents rose 19% in the year to May 2026 to 39,737 dwellings, yet residential building work fell 2.5% to $4.6 billion over the year to the March quarter. Construction costs rose 2.7% to June, driven by fuel and material prices tied to the US-Iran conflict, and HUD notes developers remain cautious about starting projects even as development lending improves.
That gap between consent and construction is exactly where escalation and substitution clauses turn from boilerplate into live risk. A buyer signing today against a consent that may sit banked for two years is taking a bet on both costs and timelines.
Trust is the real collateral
The off-plan model works when both parties believe the deal will still stack up at completion. In 2021 developers broke that trust on the upside. In 2026 the pressure comes from costs. Developers who write clean, buyer-friendly contracts now will find presales easier to secure, and banks happier to lend against them. Those who lean on the fine print will discover that buyers with the strongest balance sheets have simply stopped signing.
Sources
- NZ Herald: Buying off the plans – Risks that can change before settlement – The Prosperity Project (2026-11-21)
- NZ Herald: Buyer beware – Auckland mum warns of common contract clause that can cost home buyers dearly (2021-03-16)
- RNZ: Lawyer on sunset clauses causing trouble for home buyers (2021-11-12)
- RNZ: Off-plan property buyers should insist sunset clause removed from contracts – advisor (2021-11-24)
- 1News: Fair Go – Sunset clauses causing headaches for home buyers (2023-11-09)
- Dawsons Lawyers: Buying a property off the plans
- HUD: DOIA Response on Housing Development Challenges
- Law News: Government votes down Bill aimed at misuse of sunset clauses in off-the-plan property deals (2025-08-06)
- Law News: Coming out alive – how to deal with sunset clauses (2024-03-01)
- HUD: Housing Market Update June 2026 (2026-06)
Join the discussion
Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.