November 22, 2026

Three resilience plans later, nobody will say who pays for the next flood

A flooded road with warning signs indicating 'Road Closed Ahead' due to water overflow.

Local Government New Zealand wants the incoming Government to do something three previous policy vehicles have failed to do: write down who pays when roads, pipes and coastal assets fail. LGNZ president and Gisborne Mayor Rehette Stoltz is calling for a national climate resilience framework that allocates responsibility across central government, councils, communities and the private sector.

The ask is reasonable. The risk for business is that it produces a fourth framework heavy on “shared responsibility” and light on numbers.

The banks have stopped waiting

The trigger was Westpac’s decision to share its natural hazards risk report with home loan applicants. Head of consumer lending and insurance Jo McGregor said lending limits on exceptionally risky properties would affect fewer than 2.5% of mortgage applications. Small, but it is the private sector pricing risk because nobody else will.

Stoltz is blunt about the limits of that. “Banks and insurers cannot build flood protection, adapt infrastructure, or make the difficult decisions needed to keep communities safe,” she said. “Communities need to know what can be done, who will act and how the costs will be shared.”

She is right, and the spending mix proves it. According to the Climate Commission, 97% of government natural hazard spend goes on responding to events and just 3% on building resilience. That is the most expensive way to run a risk portfolio, and any business owner who funded maintenance that way would be out of business.

Wellington keeps changing the vehicle, not the answer

In April 2024 Cabinet scrapped the National Resilience Plan and the Climate Emergency Response Fund, returning $3.239 billion in unallocated funds to conventional Budget processes. There was a defensible fiscal logic to that: ring-fenced funds dodge trade-off scrutiny. But it meant resilience spending now competes with everything else every year.

Then came the National Adaptation Framework. In 2025, Newsroom’s analysis found it left cost-sharing unresolved, saying only that costs are “shared across society and over time”.

The Climate Change Response Amendment Bill, introduced in July, requires councils to plan for high-risk areas but establishes no dedicated funding mechanism or compensation framework. Bell Gully partner Natasha Garvan says whether central government will help with something like managed retreat is “still very much unanswered”.

The Climate Change Commission’s August progress report estimated direct costs to government and insurers from natural hazards at about $4 billion a year, and recommended the Crown clarify what it will and won’t fund. Two years, three vehicles, no formula.

Council balance sheets can’t take the hit

The uncomfortable part of LGNZ’s pitch is that councils are in no shape to carry more risk. In 2025 the Audit Office reported council debt had reached a record $29.9 billion in 2023/24, with 47 councils failing balanced budget benchmarks and some nearing borrowing limits.

The legal backstop is the 1991 Disaster Recovery Plan, under which the Crown pays up to 60% of water and sewerage restoration after a catastrophe. Back in 2013, the Audit Office found about 60% of council asset value had no insurance at all. A 35-year-old cost-sharing rule is doing the work of a modern framework.

The mismatch shows in Canterbury. Environment Canterbury chair Dr Deon Swiggs wants $240 million a year from central government for baseline flood protection. In Gisborne, a plan to retire 100,000 hectares of erosion-prone land is ready, but as Stoltz put it in June, “we need money”.

A blank cheque isn’t the fix either

Business should back a framework, but not any framework. BusinessNZ’s 2026 election priorities warn that beyond a certain point the marginal cost of resilience rises sharply while benefits diminish. That is the correct discipline. A framework that simply mandates councils to do more without funding becomes another unfunded mandate, and commercial ratepayers carry a disproportionate share of those.

Insurers want the same certainty. In 2026, ICNZ chief executive Kris Faafoi said “the proof will be in the doing” and that the challenge is moving from planning to funded delivery.

What the next coalition has to legislate

The test for the incoming Government is simple. Does it write a cost-sharing formula into law, with clear thresholds for what the Crown funds, what councils fund and what property owners carry? Or does it issue another document about shared responsibility?

For businesses with premises, fleets or supply chains in hazard zones, the second option is the expensive one. Without a rule, the bill still arrives, through rates rises, tighter lending and insurance that quietly disappears. Stoltz wants a framework that outlasts an election cycle. Business should want one with numbers in it.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required