November 20, 2026

An unlicensed adviser got a six-month head start from the watchdog

immigration, visa, caribbean

Immigration’s licensing regime only means something if operating outside it carries a quick and visible cost. In the case of Sukhdeep Kaur Gill, the Immigration Advisers Authority (IAA) took nearly eight months to have a substantive conversation with the person who reported her. Kaur Gill denies every allegation. But whatever an investigation eventually finds, the response time is the story, and it should worry every business that brings in staff through the front door.

A complaint with names, documents and a deadline nobody kept

Dr Jagjeet Singh Sidhu, president of the NZ Forum for Immigration Professionals, lodged a formal complaint on 17 March 2026, alleging Kaur Gill was acting as an unlicensed immigration adviser. The IAA replied on 20 March promising an investigator would follow up. By late August Sidhu was writing again, warning that the subject was “still practising”. The investigator’s call finally came on 2 November.

The allegations are not vague. At least 30 migrants, many of them Indian truck drivers on Accredited Employer Work Visas, say fraudulent documents were submitted to Immigration NZ in their names without their knowledge. One application included a Canadian English college certificate for a man who has never been to Canada. Another client found a Pearson test score of 59 submitted on his behalf when his real result was 29.

The money trail is just as specific. Kuljit Singh says he paid $5,000 into a Nextgen Marketing Limited account, only to discover his application had already been declined. Gagandeep Singh says he paid $3,500 for AEWV help and received a visa document Immigration NZ later told him was not genuine. Kaur Gill says she runs a digital marketing business, not an advisory practice, and denies meeting several of the migrants. Some of those affected have since lost jobs, become unlawfully present, or left the country.

The regulator explains the delay without explaining it

MBIE’s acting manager of occupational regulation, Bevan Yee, declined to say why the IAA had not moved sooner. He said investigations involve large volumes of evidence and that the authority is “actively managing increased demand”.

The demand is real. The IAA received 143 complaints in 2025-26 against 1,681 licensed advisers, up from 72 against 1,498 the year before. Complaints roughly doubled while the adviser base grew around 12%. That is a resourcing problem worth fixing. It does not explain why a complaint naming one individual, with 20-plus complainants and supporting paperwork, could not get triaged ahead of the queue. Prosecution-grade investigations take time. Picking up the phone does not.

Immigration NZ was no quicker. Licensed adviser Mehak Singh of Tegh Law, who represents 20 affected clients, says it took “half a dozen follow-ups, escalations to senior management” before her September complaint was even allocated an investigator.

Slow enforcement is a pattern, and it has been measured

This is not a one-off. In 2025, MBIE’s own regulatory impact statement on immigration penalties found exploitation complaints had risen from 807 in 2022/23 to at least 2,424 in 2024/25. The same document found 36% of investigations that did not end in prosecution in 2024 took longer than 90 days, and at least 22 cases where offending was established got no infringement notice at all because the window had closed.

The warnings go back further. In 2024, then-Deputy Public Service Commissioner Heather Baggott said Immigration NZ “could have, and should have, done more” to limit abuse of the AEWV scheme, after a review found staff concerns were treated dismissively. That same year, immigration lawyer Alastair McClymont noted that exploiters “have made their money” and got out quickly. A system that takes months to respond is built for exactly that kind of operator.

McClymont, who now represents three of the Kaur Gill complainants, says authorities still meet exploited migrants with “relative ambivalence”, preferring to remove them rather than treat them as victims.

Compliant operators are subsidising the lag

Here is the business problem. Licensed advisers pay fees, carry professional obligations and accept oversight. Unlicensed operators skip all of it. When enforcement takes six months, the licence stops being a competitive advantage and becomes a cost. Worse, licensed advisers like Mehak Singh end up doing the regulator’s legwork for free, chasing officials to act on fraud that undermines their own industry.

Employers are exposed too. Businesses using the AEWV to fill driver, construction and hospitality roles depend on a trustworthy advice channel. When fraudulent paperwork floods the system, visas get declined, workers vanish mid-contract, and Immigration NZ understandably tightens scrutiny on everyone. Accredited employers who did nothing wrong absorb the delays.

What fixing it actually looks like

This does not need another inquiry. It needs triage. Complaints naming a specific unlicensed individual, with multiple complainants and documents, should be fast-tracked, with an early warning or public notice while the full investigation runs. The IAA and Immigration NZ also need to talk to each other so two agencies are not separately sitting on the same conduct.

The government has spent two years talking tough on migrant exploitation and penalties. Tough penalties are worthless if the regulator arrives months after the money has gone. Until response times shrink, the people paying for the gap will keep being the ones who followed the rules.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required