November 20, 2026

Directors are less afraid of recession than of a country without a plan

Diverse team discussing business strategy during a meeting in a modern office setting.

New Zealand’s company directors are not panicking. They are frustrated. The Institute of Directors’ 2026 Director Sentiment Survey, run with ASB, found just 48% of directors expect the economy to improve over the next 12 months, down from 54.7% in 2025. Yet the share expecting outright decline fell to 12.6%, which BusinessDesk notes is a 10-year low in director pessimism.

Put those two numbers together and the message is plain. Boards do not think the floor is about to fall out. They just do not believe anyone has a credible plan for building on top of it.

The number that moved fastest

The drop in headline optimism will get the airtime. The figure that matters more is the 32.2% of directors who now name the lack of a long-term economic strategy as an impediment to growth, up nearly 12 points in a year. Political and policy uncertainty also climbed 6.3 points to 47.2% as a top boardroom concern, behind only global growth and geopolitical risk at 52.5%.

That is not generic gloom. It is a specific, actionable complaint from 1,126 directors surveyed between 10 August and 8 September, a period that included fuel and supply chain shocks from the US-Iran war.

IoD chief executive Kirsten Patterson put it bluntly. Directors are “making decisions about where to invest, how to improve productivity and how to prepare for the future. Those decisions are easier when there is greater certainty about the direction the country is heading.”

Translate that into capital allocation and it means deferred plant upgrades, cautious hiring and expansion plans parked until the settings look stable for longer than one electoral term.

Confident in themselves, not the country

The sharpest signal sits in the gap between how directors rate their own organisations and how they rate the economy around them. 58.2% expect their own organisation to improve, a full 10 points above their view of the national outlook.

Boards, in other words, believe their own execution is sound. What they distrust is the operating environment. That is a pointed message to policymakers of every stripe, because it shifts responsibility away from management and toward the people who set the rules.

There is a fair counter. Strategy and growth is the top board priority to the end of 2027, yet only around a third of boards regularly stress-test that strategy against future scenarios. Directors demanding a long-term plan from Wellington should be applying the same discipline at their own tables.

A two-speed boardroom

The confidence story is not uniform. Listed-company directors are the most bullish, with 70.6% expecting improvement versus just 34.5% of not-for-profit directors, the latter down sharply from 44.2% in 2025. But listed directors make up only 3.6% of the sample, so their optimism says little about the wider economy. The pessimism is concentrated in the sectors most exposed to funding decisions and policy swings.

This is drift, not recession

The wider data backs the view that the economy itself is holding up. ASB acting chief economist Kim Mundy said there are still reasons for optimism, “particularly in export-focused sectors where commodity prices and a weaker New Zealand dollar have provided support,” while noting that household spending remains under pressure.

BusinessNZ’s September forecast concluded the economy had “weathered the storm reasonably well” with solid growth expected out to 2028. The Reserve Bank’s business expectations survey shows one-year inflation expectations of 2.99%, anchored if not comfortable, alongside unemployment expectations of 5.22%.

None of that describes an economy in freefall. It describes one muddling along without a destination.

The plan nobody has written

Directors are not alone in saying so. In August, Infrastructure New Zealand chief executive Nick Leggett argued that “our public conversation focuses on managing decline rather than creating growth”, pointing to Ireland, Denmark and Canada as countries where investment follows a clear national ambition backed by bipartisan settings.

That is the real ask. Not more spending, not another growth slogan, but settings on tax, infrastructure, energy and regulation that survive a change of government. Capital is patient when it can see the road ahead. It is skittish when the rules might be rewritten every three years.

Whichever parties form the next government, the boardroom has given them a clear brief. Directors are ready to invest. They want a plan durable enough to bet on first.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required