November 18, 2026

Tobacco tax is a revenue line designed to disappear

A merchant at a store counter with various products in Ankara, Türkiye.

New Zealand’s daily smoking rate has dropped to 5.9% in 2025/26, down from 6.7% the year before and below 6% for the first time. That is roughly 32,000 fewer daily smokers in a single year. It is good news, plainly. But it also exposes an awkward truth about tobacco excise. The policy works by shrinking the thing it taxes, and the taxed market is now shrinking faster than anyone’s budget assumptions should allow.

A breakthrough after years of flatlining

The Ministry of Health’s survey puts the number of daily smokers at 259,000, down from 294,000 in the previous survey year. New Zealand now has the second-lowest smoking rate among 38 OECD countries. The biggest drop came among 25-34 year olds, from 7.9% to 5.6%.

Associate Health Minister Casey Costello noted the rate has halved over six years. “The results show the progress that’s been made from a consistent approach… That’s better for them and their families and the wider health system,” she said. After several surveys in which progress barely moved, this one marks a real inflection point, though the rate is still above the official Smokefree target of under 5% across all groups.

The customers who are left

The remaining market looks nothing like it did a decade ago. Men smoke at 7.0% against 4.9% for women, and the 45-54 and 55-64 age groups, at 9.2% and 8.0%, together account for 42% of daily smokers. Costello acknowledged that those still smoking are “mostly older, long-term smokers” and the hardest group to shift.

Maori smoking sits at 13.9%, more than double the national rate. ASH director Ben Youdan said the results show “we almost have a smokefree generation for those under 35,” but that more effort must go into older populations and persistent disparities. Vaping offers little extra relief, with daily use at 11.2%, barely changed from 11.7%.

In commercial terms, that is a price-insensitive, ageing, slowly dying customer base. Not a foundation for anyone’s growth plan, least of all Treasury’s.

A $2.2 billion market losing a fifth a year

The Ministry’s 2025 tobacco returns show $2.249 billion of smoked tobacco released to retail in calendar 2025, including $1.545 billion of cigarettes and $663 million of roll-your-own. Volume fell 22% on 2024 and 58% on 2015.

The supply side is consolidating just as fast. Only eight distributors reported sales in 2025, and British American Tobacco, Imperial and Philip Morris now hold 98% of what remains. That is what an industry managing terminal decline looks like.

The leak no tax rate can plug

The legal market is not only shrinking because people quit. Retail NZ estimates one in three cigarettes smoked here is illegal, costing $817 million in lost excise and GST. Customs seized 8.3 million smuggled cigarettes in the first four months of 2026, with Costello pointing to “this big price differential”. RNZ found illicit packs sold over Auckland counters for as little as $13, less than half the excise a legal pack carries.

Australia shows where this ends. Statisticians there estimate 80% of the market is illegal, with excise receipts falling from A$16.3 billion to A$4.1 billion in six years.

Cutting the rate would not fix it

The tempting response is to lower excise and win customers back. The evidence says otherwise. Otago University professor Janet Hoek warned any cut would trigger “a bidding war that the Government will not be able to win“, because illicit product costs almost nothing to make. Costello has since ruled out a reduction. A Post opinion piece called a cut a “classic double jeopardy“: less quitting and less revenue.

The one cut the government has pursued, a lower heated tobacco excise, has drawn fire from University of Auckland researchers, who said it benefited a single global company, Philip Morris International, without credible health evidence. Picking product winners through the tax code is exactly the kind of intervention a pro-market government should be wary of.

The smarter path is enforcement. Every illicit pack seized protects both the legal retailer and the tax base. Customs funding is a better investment than rate tinkering.

What retailers and Treasury should plan for

For dairies and service stations, tobacco has long been the foot-traffic category that got people through the door. That role is ending, and owners carrying high-value stock and security risk for a shrinking, undercut category should be repricing their floor space now.

For government, the lesson is fiscal honesty. Excise revenue should be budgeted as a declining line, because success means it trends towards zero. Counting on it to fund health spending is planning around the policy failing.

The Ministry is now drafting legislative reforms after September Cabinet decisions. The test is whether they target the illicit trade bleeding the legal market, or simply reshuffle taxes among the three companies still standing. The health goal is in sight. The revenue it leaves behind will not be.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required