November 16, 2026

Taxpayers are paying $251,000 for MBIE’s free reading habit

Three women in a modern office setting reading and working together indoors.

MBIE has agreed in principle to pay NBR $251,133.19 for passing paywalled stories around to staff who never had a licence. It is the largest payment yet in NBR’s campaign against freeloading readers. It is also a modest price for years of treating someone else’s product as a free internal resource.

The department that oversees business law, consumer protection and intellectual property policy could not keep its own staff inside a subscription agreement. That should bother anyone who has ever been on the receiving end of an MBIE compliance letter.

A habit, not a slip

This was not one overeager staffer forwarding a link. Media Insider’s reporting found paywalled NBR articles reached unlicensed MBIE staff on 8221 occasions. Official Information Act responses showed MBIE admitted sharing at least 149 articles, ahead of Inland Revenue, DIA and the SFO, as part of a wider pattern across 11 government agencies.

In July, Chief Ombudsman John Allen found MBIE’s conduct “inappropriate”, “unreasonable” and that it “appears to be contrary to law”. He called the practice systemic, flagged its frequency and duration, and recommended an apology and a remedy. MBIE deputy secretary Paul Stocks responded that the department took its copyright obligations seriously and had bought more licences and tightened guidance.

It took another four months to put a number on it.

Unlawful in the private sector, inappropriate in the public one

Retired District Court Judge David Harvey has nailed the double standard. Writing in LawNews, he points out that government agencies get gentler vocabulary than private actors: “inappropriate” rather than “unlawful”, even where the Ombudsman has said the conduct appears to break the law. A subscription is a contract. Sharing it breaches the contract. Copying the article engages the Copyright Act 1994 on top.

Harvey notes that 19 private entities caught doing the same thing settled with NBR for more than $200,000 in damages and costs, and they did so “because it was unlawful and they were liable”. His conclusion deserves to be pinned above every chief executive’s desk in Wellington: “The rule of law does not have a public-sector exemption.”

A private company with 8221 unauthorised uses would have faced lawyers’ letters, reputational damage and shareholders asking who signed off. MBIE faces a cheque drawn on the taxpayer. Nobody who presided over the practice is paying for it personally, and the department carries on as before.

The rest of the state got off lightly

The smaller settlements tell the same story. DIA paid just over $21,600 after as many as 210 unauthorised staff accessed NBR articles in 2025. The FMA first denied any breach, then found seven instances of staff sharing screenshots or PDFs, with general counsel Liam Mason apologising. The SFO shared 15 articles despite already holding 10 subscriptions. NBR is chasing Inland Revenue for $50,000.

The FMA case is the awkward one. A regulator that expects firms to self-report breaches promptly initially told a publisher it had done nothing wrong.

The trap businesses can fall into too

Before anyone in the private sector gets too smug, Inland Revenue’s paperwork shows how easily this happens. In its 2025 OIA response, IRD disclosed it cut a 220-user NBR subscription to a single seat in March 2024 over cost and low demand, while its media team kept circulating screenshots and excerpts to around 600 staff a day. IRD said it believed its Media Copyright Agency licence covered the practice. NBR had left the MCA, so it did not.

That is a mistake plenty of firms could make. Media monitoring, morning clippings emails, shared logins, a PDF dropped in the team Slack channel. Each feels internal and harmless. None of it is covered by a collective licence if the publisher has opted out, and “internal” is not a copyright defence.

Other publishers are watching

NBR believes its campaign sets a precedent for the Herald, Stuff, Are Media, ODT and Newsroom, and it has now recovered more than $500,000 across public and private targets. Publishers under financial pressure have every incentive to follow.

For business owners, the practical step is cheap: audit who is sharing what, check which licences actually cover which publishers, and buy the seats you are using. For government, the fix is cultural. Agencies that write the rules for everyone else should not need an Ombudsman, an OIA trawl and a quarter-million-dollar settlement to learn that paying for things is the law. The next publisher to come knocking will expect the same answer, and taxpayers should expect someone to be accountable when it arrives.

Sources

Reader Poll · 5 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required