The former directors of Whitianga restaurant Taj Nexus Limited appear to have assumed that closing the company and moving to Adelaide would settle the matter. It did not. The Employment Relations Authority has ordered Atul Roach and Jarmanjeet Singh to personally pay more than $113,000 in unpaid wages and holiday pay to three migrant workers. The pair closed the business in 2024 and did not take part in the investigation.
The message for employers is blunt. A payroll breach stays with the people who caused it, whether the company is closed, liquidated or the owners have moved to another country.
A year’s work for $7,185
The details are grim. Cook Kush Negi started in December 2022 and received only $7,185.97 in wages over a year, plus about $8,000 in holiday pay that was never paid. He was awarded $47,290. Fellow cook Atul Kumar was also awarded $47,290. His first three weeks in January 2023 went entirely unpaid, and his pay kept being withheld until November 2024. Duty manager Ankush Sharma was awarded $18,806.
The workers told the Authority they were threatened that the restaurant would close rather than pay what was owed. The Authority found their evidence “credible and consistent”. It also said the directors were lucky the workers had not gone to a Labour Inspector, which could have exposed them to further penalties. Payment is due by 27 November 2026, along with each worker’s $71.55 filing fee.
This was not a case of a confusing award or a payroll glitch. It was sustained, deliberate underpayment of people whose visa status made them less likely to complain.
Three sectors, one conclusion
What matters for business owners is the pattern. In June, the Authority held three directors of a fuel infrastructure company personally liable after the company went into liquidation. Two brothers had lost their jobs in December 2024 when an operations manager rang to say there was no money left. One director, based in Australia, first claimed he had no control over the business. Under sworn evidence he admitted he had given instructions to dismiss staff. All three were found to be “persons involved” in the breaches. They are jointly and severally liable for the wages, and each was fined $4,000 for aiding and abetting.
Then on 30 October, the former sole director of an Auckland painting and plastering firm was ordered to personally pay three workers $132,291.14 in unpaid wages, holiday pay and illegal premiums.
Hospitality, civil infrastructure and trades all produced the same result. Company structure, liquidation or a one-way flight across the Tasman does not separate a director from wages owed. Limited liability protects directors from ordinary company debts, but the “person involved” provisions in employment law are a deliberate exception, and the Authority is now using them routinely.
A busier, faster referee
The Authority is also getting through more cases. In 2024, lodgements rose 22% on the previous year, and 96% of its 781 determinations were issued within three months of the investigation meeting. Penalties that year ranged up to $215,000. The most common breaches were failing to keep wage and time records, Holidays Act failures and minimum wage breaches, the same categories the 2023 report flagged a year earlier.
This is not regulatory overreach. Paying people for the hours they work is the most basic part of running a business. Firms that get it right are undercut by competitors who do not, so personal liability for repeat offenders protects honest employers too.
Careless is not a defence
Not every breach is as deliberate as Whitianga. In 2024, Citation Group said most unintentional non-compliance comes from businesses misunderstanding the law or relying on payroll providers that make errors. It warned that an employer should “never blindly rely on payroll” to get entitlements right. It also said the Holidays Act makes it “very hard for a system to keep up” without human checks. The “person involved” test looks at what a director knew and did, so a director who ignores warning signs is taking a personal risk.
The policy debate is not new. In 2019, Victoria University of Wellington’s Lisa Marriott argued that New Zealand should copy Australia, Canada and the UK and make directors automatically liable for withheld amounts after a short fixed period. Parliament never adopted that scheme. The Authority is reaching similar outcomes one case at a time.
Winning is not the same as being paid
The uncomfortable part comes next. A determination against two people living in Adelaide is a legal judgment, not a bank transfer. Collecting money across the Tasman takes time, cost and persistence, and many low-paid migrant workers have little of any of those. Coverage of the ruling has largely skipped over this.
That gap should not reassure anyone tempted to try the same thing. These rulings now follow directors personally, and a personal judgment can affect future credit, directorships and business dealings in both countries. The 27 November deadline will show whether Roach and Singh pay. Either way, the Authority’s position is now clear and consistent: moving the company or the director does not cancel the wage bill.
Sources
- Waikato Times: Whitianga Indian restaurant owners liable for $113,000 unpaid wages bill (2026-11-15)
- Khanlist: Restaurant bosses withheld $113k from migrant staff before moving overseas (2026-11-15)
- Newxc: Restaurant bosses withheld $113k from migrant staff before moving overseas (2026-11-15)
- HCA Mag: Authority pins personal liability on company directors for unpaid wages (2026-07-09)
- Newswire: Managers and directors personally liable for unpaid wages, ERA (2026-11-01)
- Employment Relations Authority: Annual Report 2024 (2025-06)
- Employment Relations Authority: Annual Report 2023 (2024-05)
- Victoria University of Wellington: Who pays and who doesn’t pay when a company fails? (2019-10-21)
- Citation Group: Pinged, penalised and publicly shamed, what we can learn from Kiwi companies caught underpaying people (2024-05-22)
Join the discussion
Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.