November 20, 2026

Seven failed carbon auctions have turned the ETS into a Budget hole

mountains, fog, da lat

The emissions trading scheme is usually argued about as climate policy. It is now a fiscal problem. New modelling from Motu Economic and Public Policy Research finds the Crown could forgo around $11-12 billion in auction revenue through 2035 if it keeps putting off structural reform beyond 2030.

That is a large number for a government with little fiscal room. It is also not a distant risk. The money is already going missing.

The auctions have already stopped working

All four 2025 carbon auctions and the first three 2026 auctions drew no bids at all, seven failures in a row. Green Party analysis of Treasury data puts the resulting shortfall at $1.4 billion across the 2024 to 2026 fiscal years, against total auction proceeds of $3.8 billion from 2021 through 2025. Treasury has confirmed failed auctions add pressure to OBEGAL and debt-to-GDP, the numbers ratings agencies watch.

None of this should surprise officials. Back in 2023, Treasury flagged ETS revenue volatility as a fiscal forecasting risk. The audited Crown accounts for the year to June 2026 now record what happens when a revenue line that was always shaky stops arriving.

One policy announcement broke the price

The current slump has a clear start date. In November 2025 the government said it would “uncouple” the ETS from New Zealand’s international pledges, and the carbon price fell overnight from about $50 to as low as $33. By February 2026, officials were weighing whether to cancel auctions to force prices back up. Market participants warned that would look “unexpected and reactionary”. Ministers instead held auction volumes steady through 2030, with cuts scheduled from 2031.

That choice avoided a fresh shock. It also left the underlying flaw untouched.

Unlimited trees, shrinking demand

The flaw is forestry. Emitters can buy units from forest owners, and there is no cap on how many forestry units enter the market. Motu’s modelling shows a glut of those units colliding with falling demand from emitters who are decarbonising anyway. By the mid-2030s, the government loses the ability to run meaningful auctions, let alone earn from them. New Zealand would briefly touch net zero, then slide back as the incentive collapses.

The Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment reached the same place in August, calling the scheme “rudderless”. Its Adrift report counted a stockpile of 121.2 million units as of May 2026, 29.7 million of them surplus, roughly a year’s worth of covered emissions. Under current settings auctioned volumes fall from 4.3 million units in 2027 to 1.1 million in 2031, heading towards almost nothing by 2034. The price has swung between $35 and $85 since 2021. Try building a capital plan for a process heat conversion on that.

Let the price do the work

Motu’s fix is market-based, which is why it deserves a hearing from people who distrust subsidies. Take forestry out of the ETS, honour existing stockpiled credits, and let a leaner scheme produce a real price signal. Lead author Catherine Leining, a Motu policy fellow and former climate change commissioner, argues the scheme conflates cutting emissions with removing carbon. “They’re actually very different, and New Zealand needs both,” she says.

Auction revenue from a functioning market would fund a separate removals mechanism for foresters, and Motu’s modelling finds the Crown still comes out ahead. Leining wants the work to start now, with a staged transition so that “no one is worse off”.

The government’s answer so far is pedigree. At this week’s global climate summit, caretaker climate minister Simon Watts pointed to New Zealand’s ETS being the second oldest in the world. Age is not a defence of design. Choosing stability through 2030 is precisely what sets up the 2035 cliff.

Business wants rules that stay put

Business is not demanding a winner in the forestry versus emitters fight. In 2025, BusinessNZ and the BusinessNZ Energy Council argued that “persistent regulatory uncertainty has weakened the signal given by carbon price” and that “constant interference should therefore be avoided”. They wanted settings legislated out to at least 2035 instead of revisited annually.

That request and Motu’s reform are compatible. A one-off structural fix, legislated and left alone, delivers both the certainty firms asked for and the revenue the Crown is losing. Tinkering every year delivers neither.

The bill lands after the election

Whoever forms the next government inherits a scheme that is failing on its own terms and costing real money. The fiscal hole is already $1.4 billion deep and Motu’s numbers show where it goes next. Reform takes years to do properly, and the 2031 volume cuts are not far off. The incoming minister can start the redesign in 2027, or explain to Treasury in 2035 why $12 billion never turned up.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required