Evan Davies, the Crown manager running delivery of the New Dunedin Hospital inpatient building, has had his $2500-a-day contract extended. The day rate will draw the outrage. The bigger issue is that an intervention designed as a short-term rescue is now 17 months old, and nobody has said publicly what would have to happen for it to end.
An emergency power with no end date
Cabinet appointed Davies on 16 June 2025 under section 63 of the Pae Ora Act, which lets the Health Minister install a Crown manager where there is a risk to Health NZ’s operation or long-term viability. The same decision required the need for a Crown manager to be reviewed no later than every twelve months. That threshold has now been passed at least once, and the role continues. Whatever that review concluded, its reasoning has not been put in front of taxpayers.
The original case was strong. The Cabinet paper released in January 2026 described the project as the largest health infrastructure investment in New Zealand’s history, with a $1.88 billion construction budget making up nearly 30% of Health NZ’s entire physical infrastructure portfolio. It said Health NZ “has experienced consistent challenges in delivering the project” and had acknowledged “a lack of internal capability”.
The June 2025 briefing to then Health Minister Simeon Brown laid out the history: a budget that had climbed from $1.4 billion under Labour to $1.88 billion, after the coalition paused the project in 2024 and pared back scope before restarting it at the higher figure. Both sides of the House own a piece of this mess.
The day rate is the distraction
In January 2026, the Herald reported Davies’ rate was more than double what he had been paid for earlier Dunedin hospital governance roles, and was set to match Health NZ chair Lester Levy, whose fees could reach $450,000 for the year across 130 days plus 50 contingency days. The Cabinet paper called the rate consistent with the Cabinet Fees Framework.
Do the maths and the fee barely registers. Even 180 days a year at $2500 comes to $450,000, roughly 0.02% of the $1.88 billion budget. If Davies keeps that number from blowing out, he is cheap.
The sharper question is capacity. Davies remains group chief executive of Todd Corporation, and in January 2026 he did not respond to questions about how he would fit the Crown role around a fulltime executive job. On a project of this scale, part-time oversight is a choice the Crown should be able to defend.
Shared-risk contracts need a permanent referee
The strongest case for keeping Davies lies in the contract itself. In September 2025 Health NZ signed CPB Contractors on a collaborative, not fixed-price, model. Treasury’s advice, reported in March 2026, was blunt: the deal “engages a delivery model that is untested in New Zealand, which poses an ongoing risk of cost escalations.” Treasury conceded a safer deal could not have been struck without significant further delay. By then the inpatient building’s opening had already slid from 2028 to 2031.
Under shared risk, the Crown needs someone senior at the table every week, arguing cost and scope with a contractor whose incentives are not identical to the taxpayer’s. Remove that person and the risk Treasury flagged lands back on an organisation that admitted it lacked the capability to manage it.
In 2025, former Labour health minister Pete Hodgson defended the approach, arguing Davies had persuaded the government that shared risk was the only workable option and that the September 2024 ministerial halt had cost roughly a year and about $40 million in inflation. That is a pointed reminder that political stop-start can cost more than any consultant.
Fixers become fixtures when nothing else changes
When the appointment was announced, the role was framed as freeing Health NZ to focus on other infrastructure work programmes. That is the trap. Every board that has parachuted in a turnaround specialist knows the risk: the organisation stops building its own muscle because someone else is carrying the weight. Seventeen months on, there is no public sign Health NZ is any closer to running a project like this itself.
Extending Davies is probably the right call for now. Changing horses mid-build on an untested contract would be worse. But the Crown owes taxpayers three things: the outcome of the 12-month review, a plan to transfer capability back into Health NZ, and hard milestones against the $1.88 billion cap. Without them, the meter keeps running and the intervention quietly becomes the system.
Sources
- ODT: Crown manager paid $2.5k a day to lead new Dunedin hospital project given contract extension (2026-11-16)
- Ministry of Health: Minute of Decision CAB-25-MIN-0197 (2025-06-16)
- Ministry of Health: Cabinet paper, appointment of a Crown manager to the NDH inpatient building project (2026-01)
- Ministry of Health: Briefing for Decision H2025068289 (2025-06-13)
- NZ Herald: $2500 a day, Dunedin hospital Crown manager’s fee more than doubles from previous roles (2026-01-18)
- Newsroom: Treasury warns of ‘risky’, ‘untested’ Dunedin hospital contract (2026-03-10)
- ODT: Has the government finally come to its senses? (2025-07-01)
- Scoop: Crown Manager appointed to drive delivery of New Dunedin Hospital (2026-05)
Join the discussion
Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.