November 20, 2026

Half of KiwiSaver withdrawals now happen exactly where advice runs out

Financial advisor discussing documents with senior clients in an office setting, showcasing a collaborative consulting session.

KiwiSaver is very good at one job. It gets people to 65 with a pot of money. Then, at the moment that money is most exposed to bad decisions, the system hands most members a pamphlet and wishes them luck.

That is the real message behind the Financial Markets Authority’s push for more advice at KiwiSaver access age, a push providers now broadly agree with. Agreeing is the easy part. The harder admission is that fund managers, advisers and employers built an accumulation machine and never built the drawdown infrastructure to match it.

The money is already moving

This is not a future problem. Over-65s withdrew $3.3 billion in the FMA’s latest annual report year, up 10.5% and nearly half of every dollar taken out of KiwiSaver. That is more than first-home buyers and hardship applicants combined.

The pipeline behind it is large and growing. The Retirement Commission counts 299,087 accounts closed after members turned 65 between 2013 and 2025, with 237,634 over-65s still holding open accounts. In 2025, the Commission’s Patrick Nolan said half a million more KiwiSavers would reach 65 over the next decade, and that the country had “not given them enough help” to work out what to do with their balances.

The regulator has already named the gap

The FMA did not mince words in March. “While advice on establishing and growing KiwiSaver is available, we observed an advice gap for consumers close to or post-retirement,” its sector report said, flagging sequence-of-returns risk: a bad market early in retirement, combined with withdrawals, can drain savings far faster than expected.

Romil Ghelani, the FMA’s head of financial advice, told RNZ in August that professional advice is “commonly catered towards higher-net-worth clients”, while everyone else gets generic information. He called the 65 transition one of the hardest financial moves a person makes.

The consumer data makes it worse. The FMA’s own research found 65% of people rated their confidence managing KiwiSaver after retirement at four or five out of five, and willingness to seek advice rises with wealth. Put simply, the people with the smallest balances and the least margin for error are the least likely to ask for help, and the most likely to think they don’t need it.

Providers are saying the right things now

Credit where due. Pie Funds chief executive Ana-Marie Lockyer concedes the industry has “focused heavily on helping people accumulate” and needs to support drawdown too. Fisher Funds’ Robyn Conway says members have been conditioned to think they must pull everything out at 65, despite most living another 20-plus years. Milford sends pre-65 emails and offers an online drawdown tool.

But emails and tools are guidance, not advice. Consilium’s Ben Brinkerhoff put it plainly: advised clients rarely hit these transitions in distress, “it’s those who don’t have advice that concern me more.” He wants easier access to advice that is independent of whoever holds the account, which is a polite way of noting that the provider has a commercial interest in where the money goes next.

The industry was warned. In 2025, Koura Wealth founder Rupert Carlyon said providers spent plenty of effort getting members in the door but “nowhere near enough on education”, arguing the pitch should be about setting people up to 95, not 65.

Fewer cash-outs is not the same as good decisions

There is a positive reading. In the year to March 2025, over-65 withdrawal counts fell 14.1% to 31,470, and the share of over-65s with an open account climbed from 16% in 2016 to 26% in 2025. More retirees are staying invested, and 40% of over-65 members kept contributing.

That is welcome, but staying put by default is not a plan. Someone who parks everything in a conservative fund at 65 because they assume they should is making a decision with 25-year consequences, unadvised.

Employers are in this whether they like it or not

For business owners with ageing workforces, this is a live HR issue. Staff approaching 65 are about to make the largest financial decision most of them will ever make, inside a system the regulator says underserves them. Employers already run KiwiSaver deductions and pay contributions. Funding a session with an independent adviser for staff in the two years before 65 is cheap relative to the goodwill, retention and late-career planning certainty it buys.

The fix is not more compulsion or another government scheme. It is a market opportunity that the advice sector, providers and employers have been slow to price. A $138.8 billion industry can build decumulation advice that reaches the median member, not just the wealthy one. The FMA has made the diagnosis. The next test is whether providers turn their newfound candour into products, fee structures and employer partnerships before the next half-million members hit the cliff.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required