November 19, 2026

A dead heat with Australia on worker wellbeing is nothing to celebrate

A woman sitting at a desk with her hands on her head, appearing stressed and tired with office supplies around her.

New Zealand has finally closed the wellbeing gap with Australia, and almost nobody should be popping champagne. Telus Health’s latest Mental Health Index, run on both sides of the Tasman over the same fortnight, put NZ workers on 62.2 out of 100 against Australia’s 62.5. That is a statistical tie, after years in which Australia sat comfortably ahead.

The company behind the numbers is blunt about why. Telus Health managing director Jamie MacLennan points to five consecutive Reserve Bank of Australia rate rises and a cost-of-living tipping point across the ditch. “I think it’s more deterioration on this side of the pond than New Zealand getting better, unfortunately,” he says.

For NZ employers, that distinction matters. A rival stumbling is not the same as you getting faster.

Staying put is not the same as being happy

The rest of this month’s data makes the point. HP research shows 60% of NZ desk-based workers believe it is too risky to leave their current job. Yet Robert Walters’ latest salary guide finds 56% of employees are looking to change jobs in the next 12 months, up from 53% last year.

Put those together and you get a workforce that wants out but is too nervous to move. That is not loyalty. It is a holding pattern, and holding patterns end the moment the job market loosens. Any employer reading low turnover as proof their culture is working is likely mistaking fear for satisfaction.

The stress indicators back this up. Gallup’s 2026 workplace report found 45% of NZ employees reported high daily stress, two points above the prior three-year average and well above the global rate of 40%. Trust is eroding among the workers businesses will depend on longest. MBIE’s 2025 Employment Monitor recorded high trust in employers among 18 to 29-year-olds falling 10 points to 16% in a single year.

Australia still holds the pay advantage

The convergence in sentiment also masks a gap in hard numbers. University of Auckland associate professor Alan Toy notes NZ salary and wage rates grew just 2% in the year to June 2026 against 4.1% inflation, while Australian wages grew 3.2% against 3.8% inflation. Kiwi workers went backwards in real terms by roughly twice as much.

Toy links part of that to Australia’s 2022 compulsory arbitration mechanism, which lets the Fair Work Commission set terms when bargaining deadlocks. Business owners will rightly be wary of importing a regulator with the power to impose pay outcomes on firms whose revenue isn’t growing. But the underlying point stands. Once the RBA stops hiking and Australian households stabilise, the structural pay gap will reassert itself, and so will the pull across the Tasman.

Employers know they are falling behind. Only 28% now think salaries are keeping pace with the cost of living, down from 40% a year ago.

Pay is not the only lever, but it is not optional either

The honest problem is that most firms can’t simply write bigger cheques. Margins are thin and revenue growth is patchy. That is why the non-salary levers deserve more attention than they typically get. The BusinessNZ and Southern Cross Workplace Wellness Report 2025 identified workload, change at work, job uncertainty and long hours as the top drivers of work-related stress. Every one of those is something managers control directly.

There is also a commercial case, not just a pastoral one. HP found that at businesses that performed extremely well over the past year, 51% of employees reported a healthy relationship with work, versus 17% at firms with static growth. Causation runs both ways, but the correlation is too large to wave away. Firms that manage workload and uncertainty well tend to be the ones growing.

It is worth remembering how fragile Kiwi goodwill can be. In 2025, Hays found 64% of New Zealanders were satisfied with their salary versus 60% of Australians, despite earning less. Workers here have historically tolerated lower pay for other things. That tolerance is being tested by two years of real wage decline.

The window is closing

The Telus Health result buys NZ employers time, nothing more. Australia’s slump has temporarily removed the most obvious exit route for frustrated staff, and the local job market is keeping people in their seats. Both conditions are temporary.

The businesses that use this breathing space to fix workloads, communicate clearly through change and target pay where it counts will keep their best people when the market turns. The ones that read a tied scoreboard as a win will find out in 2027 how many of their staff were only staying because they had nowhere else to go.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required