November 17, 2026

Pausing the rates cap for ECan would hand every council an excuse

Deon Swiggs in Council Chamber (cropped)

Environment Canterbury wants the Government to stop the clock on rates capping. In its submission on the Local Government (Rates Capping) Amendment Bill, the regional council asks for the cap to be paused until the sector works through a new planning regime, possible amalgamation and the proposed abolition of regional councils, ECan included. A pause, ECan argues, would “enable fundamental decisions related to the functions and form of regional government to be determined before establishing the funding system required to deliver it”.

As a sequencing argument, it sounds tidy. As a precedent, it is dangerous. Every council in the country has some reform, review or restructure on its horizon. If uncertainty is grounds for a pause, the cap never starts.

The cap ECan is trying to outrun

The bill sets a 2-4% target range on non-water rates, covering general rates, targeted rates and uniform annual general charges, while excluding water services rates and fees. Local Government Minister Simon Watts justified it in September by pointing to median council rates increases of 14.2% and 9.2% over the two preceding years, saying ratepayers had been hit with steep and unexpected increases for far too long.

The gap between where councils are and where the Government wants them is enormous. A parliamentary written answer shows that for 2026/27, 65 councils set increases above 4%, just nine landed inside the 2-4% range and only four came in below 2%. The exemption process will not be a rare safety valve. It will be the main event.

A finance director’s warning

ECan’s own numbers explain the timing of its request. In October, financial director Giles Southwell told councillors the council faced a “frightening picture”. Starting from a 6% increase, roughly $12m, spending requests already on the table could push rates up 10% or more, about $21m in new spending. ECan has provisionally set aside $10 million over two years for amalgamation transition costs, and preliminary modelling put its 10-year shortfall at $418m under a 4% cap and $604m at 2%.

Not everyone at the table thought the answer was more money. Ngāi Tahu councillor Megen McKay said “sometimes doing less is the right solution”. That is the argument the cap is designed to force, and the one a pause would postpone.

Councils do have a point on costs

It would be lazy to dismiss the sector entirely. BERL’s local government cost index sits at 6.5% against CPI of 3.7% for the September quarter, driven by fuel, bitumen and construction. A Waimakariri spokesperson noted councils “were not in the business of buying groceries”, and flagged that the Rangiora eastern link road may no longer stack up under the new limit.

PSA-commissioned modelling by Victor Consulting puts the potential shortfall for the 25 largest councils at up to $4.2 billion over seven years under a 4% cap from 2027, with Greater Christchurch facing revenue reductions of $80-458 million. The union has an obvious interest, but the direction of travel is plausible. A cap forces trade-offs. That is rather the point.

The flaw business should actually worry about

The sharper problem for commercial ratepayers is not the pause. It is the design. New Zealand Initiative senior fellow Nick Clark points out the cap applies to a council’s average rates per property, not individual bills. Revaluations, differentials and targeted rates can still push a commercial property’s bill well past 4% while the council stays technically compliant. Councils looking for headroom will know exactly which ratepayers have the least political weight.

Clark is also blunt about the number itself: “the workings keep changing, but the answer never moves from 2-4%”, and officials’ own impact analysis could not say the cap beat doing nothing. He points to New South Wales, which has pegged rates since 1977 and where nearly every council eventually sought exemptions. The Ministry’s summary of underpinning analysis deserves closer scrutiny at select committee for exactly that reason.

Fix the cap, don’t freeze it

The Government should say no to ECan. The bill already carries exemption routes for exceptional circumstances and future financial planning. A council whose very existence is under review is precisely the case those mechanisms were built for, assessed on evidence, case by case, not a blanket pause that every other council can cite.

Where Wellington should listen is on design. Measuring compliance against average bills invites cost-shifting onto businesses, and an exemption system used by most councils risks becoming a rates negotiation with an extra layer of central bureaucracy. Close the averages loophole, publish exemption decisions in full, and give ratepayers a binding say on big projects. If ministers hold the line on timing and fix the mechanics, the cap might actually discipline council spending. If they pause it for ECan, ratepayers should assume it was never going to.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required