November 16, 2026

Politics is chasing a permanent job market employers have quietly abandoned

Hot Desk

New Zealand’s unemployment rate reached 5.7 percent in the September 2026 quarter, or 174,000 people, the highest since the global financial crisis. Nearly every political response assumes the same fix: stimulate demand, wait for the cycle to turn, and the old jobs will refill. That assumption is looking shaky. Employers are restructuring how they hire, AI is already cutting roles in healthy businesses, and the country’s most senior employment judge is warning the legal model itself may not survive.

The cycle is real, but it is not the whole story

The deterioration is recent and accelerating. Reserve Bank data shows unemployment rising from 5.4 percent in March to 5.6 percent in June and 5.7 percent in September, with hourly earnings growth slowing to 2.9 percent. Back in the December 2025 quarter, Stats NZ had unemployment at 5.4 percent and underutilisation at 13.0 percent. Underutilisation is now 13.8 percent, youth unemployment is 16.9 percent, and one in five jobless people have been out of work for more than a year.

Economist and EEO Commissioner Gail Pacheco rightly identifies weak demand as the main driver, hitting construction, hospitality and retail hardest. But she plays down the contracting trend, noting that “the vast majority of workers are in permanent positions”. That is true of the stock of jobs. It says much less about the flow of new ones.

Employers are hiring around the rules

Quarterly data cited by Andrew Barnes shows casual employment up 19.5 percent and fixed-term employment up 18.9 percent. His explanation will be uncomfortable for those who designed the current settings: rising minimum wages lift the cost of permanent staff, dismissal law makes underperformers hard to remove, so firms limit permanent hires and fill the gaps with casual and fixed-term labour.

The workers on the receiving end lose sick leave, holiday pay and KiwiSaver contributions. Barnes also asks whether the shift is spreading into white-collar work, with employers offloading expensive permanent staff because they do not know how many people AI will leave them needing. That is the real feedback loop: protections built around the permanent job are making the permanent job harder to justify.

AI is already writing the redundancy letters

This is no longer hypothetical. RNZ reports a business where about 60 people were affected after the employer mandated an AI platform, despite the company not being in financial trouble. Woolworths moved customer care to Australia, cutting more than 130 jobs, after New Zealand staff had trained the AI model now training their replacements. Massey University economist Matt Roskruge notes AI does not need to replace whole jobs to cause redundancies, and new roles may not appear as fast as old ones vanish.

The professional class is next in line

The exposure does not fall where past automation did. In February 2026, Reserve Bank analysts found AI exposure was most strongly linked to professional, managerial and administrative roles earning $50,000 to $150,000. About 30 percent of workers faced high combined AI and robotics exposure, and fewer than 5 percent faced low exposure. Treasury had flagged the same white-collar risk in 2024, along with a warning that New Zealand’s slow technology diffusion could blunt the productivity upside.

The first rung is coming off the ladder

In April 2026, University of Auckland professor Rod McNaughton reported that more than half of NZ employers surveyed said AI was driving significant job displacement and slowing or stopping entry-level hiring, with nearly nine in ten expecting further slowdowns. The routine, data-heavy tasks AI handles best are exactly the ones graduates used to learn on. Youth unemployment of 16.9 percent is a cyclical problem stacked on a structural one.

Trust was already thin. In 2025, MBIE found 69 percent of workers believed their employer could easily replace them, and only 16 percent of young workers reported high trust in their employer. Conditions have worsened since.

Even the courts admit the law is behind

Employment Court Chief Judge Christina Inglis has warned that full-time employment may become the exception, and that the employer-employee relationship could “morph beyond recognition or disappear entirely”. “What if the actual relationship is triangular or quadrilateral or distributed across a global network?” she asked, questioning whether existing legal concepts should be stretched, abandoned or reimagined. When the judiciary says this out loud, policymakers have no excuse for pretending otherwise.

Plan for the market that exists

For business owners, the lesson is to stop treating this as a blip. Workforce plans, training budgets and wage settings should assume a durably more contingent labour market. Firms that keep investing in junior staff will own a scarce pipeline of skilled people in five years, when competitors who froze graduate hiring discover there is nobody to promote.

For politicians heading into the election, the test is whether anyone will design employment law, skills funding and portable benefits for a workforce that moves between contracts, rather than promising to restore a model employers are already leaving. Lowering the unemployment rate matters. Pretending the jobs that come back will look like the ones that left does not.

Sources

Reader Poll · 5 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required