November 21, 2026

ACC levies are rising no matter who wins the affordability argument

Two construction workers with hard hats assist an injured team member, highlighting workplace safety.

Mike Hosking has asked the question politicians avoid. If New Zealand can debate whether Super is affordable, why not ACC? He pays about $3,500 a year in levies, has never claimed in 45 years, and resents subsidising gardening injuries that run to roughly 200 claims a day.

It is a fair question. But for business owners the debate is partly academic. The next round of levy increases is already priced in, the scheme’s turnaround plan has not closed the hole, and a meaningful slice of the cost growth comes from courts and markets rather than careless gardeners.

The bill is already printed

ACC’s 2026 annual report showed a $961 million net deficit for the year to 30 June. That beat a budgeted $2.9 billion loss, but every account is still underfunded for 2026/27: Motor Vehicle by $382 million, Work by $161 million, Earners’ by $534 million and Non-Earners’ by $761 million. That is more than $1.8 billion in shortfalls in a single year.

Businesses are already paying for it. The motor vehicle levy has climbed from $113.94 to $131.94 per vehicle over two years, and the work levy has moved from $0.66 to $0.69 per $100 of payroll. ACC’s own pricing work shows the new-year cost of motor vehicle claims sitting at $233 to $247 per vehicle through 2027/28, well above what is being charged. A fleet operator should read that as a multi-year cost escalator, not a one-off.

The turnaround has not turned yet

In January 2026 ACC unveiled a plan to avoid a $26 billion deficit by 2030, hiring 285 more claims staff and admitting an “overly generous approach” had led to over-servicing. Then-board chair Jan Dawson warned that without action “the scheme will become unaffordable”.

The underlying trend explains the alarm. Nine percent of injured people now still need weekly payments a year after injury, up from 5% a decade ago, and rehabilitation costs have doubled from $2.1 billion to $4.4 billion. In 2025 Treasury said many people stuck in the two-to-seven-year weekly compensation cohort had low-complexity injuries. That is where genuine savings lie, and the scheme deserves credit for finally chasing them.

Some of the cost has nothing to do with claimants

Here is what the entitlement debate misses. Sensitive claims, mostly historic abuse, added $541 million to the outstanding claims liability in 2024/25 after a December 2023 Court of Appeal ruling widened eligibility for backdated compensation. Deputy chief executive Stewart McRobie calls the area “an area of ongoing focus and risk for the Scheme.” No employer safety programme touches that.

Investment markets matter just as much. The 2024 shortfall of $7.2 billion shrank to $1.5 billion a year later largely on share market returns. Back in 2024, economist Susan St John noted that deficit was driven by an $8.7 billion actuarial revision of existing claims, not a sudden wave of bad behaviour.

Hosking’s fix reaches only part of the problem

Trimming low-severity claims has appeal, and the fiscal presentation deserves scrutiny too. Hosking is right that splitting the government’s headline into OBEGAL and an ACC-excluded measure makes the pressure easier to look past. But gardening claims costing $120 million a year are small against $8 billion in annual treatment and compensation. The money is in long-duration claims and liabilities the scheme cannot control.

The business lobby has been blunt about the stakes. In 2024, then-BusinessNZ chief executive Katherine Rich called underfunding “intergenerational theft”, warning the Earners’ Account would still be 23% unfunded by 2028 even with maximum levy rises. From the other side, St John argued in 2025 for scrapping full funding and risk-rating in favour of a simple flat levy. Both camps agree the current architecture is not working.

The self-employed pay full freight for partial cover

The sharpest inequity lands on contractors and sole traders. They face rising levies but ACC covers accidents only, not illness, and weekly compensation is calculated from prior-year tax returns that often understate current income. A builder with cancer gets nothing from the scheme he has funded for decades.

Plan for the trend, not the reform

Work claims hit 82,530 in the first half of 2026, costing $567.7 million, on track to rival 2025’s record. ACC’s own 2025 annual report warned that prolonged underfunding means “future generations will pay higher levies”.

The affordability debate is worth having, and the 2026 election is the place to have it. But no party can legislate away court rulings or a bad year on the share market. Employers should budget for levies to keep climbing, invest in workplace safety where it actually moves their risk rating, and make sure self-employed staff have income protection that ACC will never provide.

Sources

Reader Poll · 6 questions

Do you agree or disagree with the following?

Community

Join the discussion

Add useful context, ask a good question, or challenge an idea — keep it specific and respectful.

Create a commenter account

Enter the name you want shown publicly and your email. We will email you a password-set link; you cannot comment until you use it.

Your email is used for sign-in and account security. It is not published with comments.

Subscribe for weekly news

Subscribe For Weekly News

* indicates required